Illinois Senior Vice Commander Bobby Welch has done yeoman work researching the history of badges in the VFW and has accumulated a large collection of memorabilia. The lineage of the VFW as we know it can be summed up in the photo below, with these two cases of medals.
The small case on the left is a membership medal and lapel pin for the
American Veterans of Foreign Service (AVFS), founded in 1899. This is the
founding organization of the VFW, all the other organizations merged into the AVFS
to eventually become the VFW. There were two separate branches of the AVFS...Columbus, OH and Altoona, PA. This medal is the Columbus branch. The two merged
in 1905. The case on the right has a Membership medal for the National
Society Army of the Philippines (NSAP) founded in 1899, a card from Bailey,
Banks & Biddle (the sole maker of the medal), and a 5th reunion button for the society from 1905.
Below is a sample of Comrade Welch's collection of the many VFW membership badges and styles over the 120 plus years of our organization.